Baseball gloves come in all shapes and sizes these days, but for many players, the debate comes down to two of the most popular styles – Rawlings Thermoformed gloves vs. BOA gloves.
As a long-time player and coach, I’ve had the chance to test out both types extensively and want to provide a comprehensive rundown of the key differences, pros and cons, and help you determine which option might be best for your specific needs and preferences.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Rawlings Thermoformed | BOA |
| Break-In Time | Short break-in period | Slightly longer break-in |
| Adjustability | Lace-up allows some adjustability | Micro-adjustable dial provides precision fit |
| Durability | Extremely durable construction | Durable but dial hardware less proven |
| Comfort | Lightweight flexible feel | Snug, constricted fit can be tight |
| Quality of Materials | Full-grain leathers used | Leather quality varies more |
| Pricing | Wide range, excellent value | Limited models, premium pricing |
| Style Variety | Many styles and colors | Fewer model options currently |
| Position Suitability | Options for all positions except catcher | Mainly infielder gloves so far |
Overview of Rawlings Thermoformed Gloves
Rawlings revolutionized the baseball glove game when they introduced their thermoformed gloves in the 1970s. The thermoformed process uses heat and pressure to compress and shape the glove, essentially “baking” it into form. T
his gives the glove structure and shape right off the shelf, reducing the traditional break-in time required for high-quality leather gloves.
Some of the standout features of Rawlings thermoformed gloves include:
- Short break-in time – Ready for game action much faster than traditional gloves
- Lightweight feel – Thermoformed compression gives a flexible, responsive feel
- Consistent shape – The formed shape remains consistent over time
- Wide range of styles – Pro styles like Heart of the Hide and recreational models
- All-leather construction – Made from full-grain leather with wool padding
The Rawlings thermoformed technique allows them to produce gloves with great consistency since each one holds its shape.
This lends itself well for mass production while still using high-quality materials.
The downside is that some players feel thermoformed models lack the customization and nuanced feel that comes with breaking in a tradition glove over time.
But for an off-the-shelf glove ready for immediate action, it’s hard to beat Rawlings thermoformed.
Most Popular Rawlings Thermoformed Gloves
Some of the most popular Rawlings thermoformed glove lines include:
- Heart of the Hide – Made from premium steer hide leather and known for its durability and performance. A popular pro model glove.
- Pro Preferred – Professional-level glove that’s hand-formed shaping for precision. Uses soft European Kip leather.
- Gold Glove – Recreational model glove designed for affordability and ease of use. Uses full-grain leather.
- Primo – Youth model focused on an easy break-in and adjustability for growing hands. Quality leather build.
Overview of BOA Gloves
BOA gloves take a different approach to production by using a micro-adjustable dial closure system rather than traditional laces. This BOA dial system allows you to quickly tighten or loosen your glove for a custom fit and feel.
Some benefits of BOA glove models include:
- Easy adjustability – Dial provides precision tightening/loosening anytime
- Snug, secure fit – BOA system pulls glove firmly around the hand
- Quick break-in – Snug fit helps break in glove quicker
- Good for growing hands – Easily adjust fit as hands grow
- Unique style – Modern look and tech feel from dial closure
BOA gloves are constructed from quality leather materials and padding just like traditional gloves. The difference comes in the closure.
While the BOA system offers quick adjustability, some players still prefer the classic lace-up style and nuanced feel it provides during break-in.
But for those wanting a consistent, snug fit game to game, BOA delivers.
Most Popular BOA Gloves
Some top BOA glove models include:
- Wilson A2000 – Iconic Wilson glove updated with BOA dial closure system
- Rawlings REV1X – BOA dial system on Rawlings training and youth gloves
- Nokona Alpha – High-end custom glove with BOA closure added
- Marucci ADA – Excellent BOA dial glove designed for adjustability
Now that we’ve covered the general pros and cons of Rawlings thermoformed and BOA gloves, let’s dig into a detailed feature comparison.
Detailed Feature Comparison of Rawlings Thermoformed And BOA Gloves
Here is an in-depth look at how Rawlings thermoformed and BOA gloves stack up across essential factors:
- Break-In Time
Rawlings Thermoformed – The formed shape means minimal break-in out of the wrapper. Expect just a few practices to fully break it in.
BOA – The micro-adjustable fit can be tightened for a snug feel that breaks in faster. Break-in time slightly longer than thermoformed but still quicker than traditional.
Advantage: Rawlings Thermoformed
- Adjustability
Rawlings Thermoformed – Lace-up style allows for some adjustability as the glove breaks in. But limited compared to BOA.
BOA – The dial system allows you to quickly fine-tune the fit as needed. Easily adjust tightness inning by inning if desired.
Advantage: BOA
- Durability
Rawlings Thermoformed – Full-grain, all-leather construction is built to handle wear and tear over many seasons. Pro models have excellent durability.
BOA – Also made from quality leather materials with strong stitching and structural design. Dial hardware adds potential durability concerns.
Advantage: Rawlings Thermoformed
- Comfort
Rawlings Thermoformed – Lightweight feel from compression forming allows good flexibility and response. Broken-in comfort is excellent.
BOA – Dial system’s snug fit hugs the hand comfortably. But some may dislike constricted feel vs. lace-up models.
Advantage: Toss up based on preference
- Quality of Materials
Rawlings Thermoformed – Models at all price points use full-grain leather hides and wool padding for quality construction.
BOA – Leather quality varies more widely by price. But most use high-end leather along with padding for shape retention.
Advantage: Rawlings Thermoformed
- Pricing
Rawlings Thermoformed – Wide range available from $50+ entry models up to $400 pro gloves. Good value across lineup.
BOA – Currently limited models with premium pricing of $250+ required for BOA tech. Less budget options.
Advantage: Rawlings Thermoformed
- Style Variety
Rawlings Thermoformed – Many color and style options across their thermoformed lineup to match preferences.
BOA – Currently less model options to choose from. Dial closure provides a sleek, modern aesthetic.
Advantage: Rawlings Thermoformed
- Position Suitability
Rawlings Thermoformed – Models readily available for all positions except catcher. Designed for utility players.
BOA – Primarily geared toward infielders thus far. Catcher’s mitt options starting to emerge.
Advantage: Rawlings Thermoformed
Additional Factors to Consider
Beyond the core features above, here are a few other factors to weigh:
- Feel – Rawlings thermoformed offers a more broken-in, game-ready feel immediately, while BOA provides more customization during break-in. depends on your preferences.
- Brand Loyalty – Those who swear by heart of the Hide likely won’t switch. Similarly for Wilson or Marucci BOA fans.
- Growing Hands – BOA may allow more room for adjustment as young player’s hands grow.
- Re-Sale Value – Thermoformed models tend to retain value well if reselling used glove. BOA resale market unproven.
- Weather Conditions – BOA dial can be finicky in extreme cold or muddy conditions. Thermoformed performs consistently.
Consider how these additional factors align with your needs and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Here are answers to some common questions about Rawlings thermoformed and BOA gloves:
Rawlings does not currently manufacture any gloves with the BOA dial closure system. BOA is a technology used by other glove brands like Wilson and Marucci. Rawlings uses traditional lacing or Velcro on their gloves.
Yes, unfortunately there are counterfeit Rawlings gloves on the market, particularly online from some unknown sellers. To ensure authenticity, purchase directly from Rawlings or authorized retailers. Signs of a fake include poor quality materials and craftsmanship.
Both Heart of the Hide and Pro Preferred are premium Rawlings gloves made from high quality leather. Heart of the Hide is known for its durability and stability over years of use. Pro Preferred uses softer leather that offers more flexibility right away. Pro Preferred is better for quick break-in while Heart of the Hide optimizes for longevity.
Rawlings uses several high quality leather types including:
1. Pro Preferred: Made from full-grain Kip leather from top steer hides
2. Heart of Hide: Uses premium steer hides and palm lining
3. Gold Glove: Constructed from full-grain oiled leather
They also use wool padding in most gloves for shape retention and comfort.
The Bottom Line
When choosing between Rawlings thermoformed and BOA dial closure gloves, there’s no universally superior option. Rawlings thermoformed offers fast break-in with excellent quality and durability. BOA provides unmatched adjustability and quick break-in.
Consider which features align best with your preferences and needs at your position. Thermoformed is likely the safer choice, while BOA offers more innovation. Try out both styles if possible to gauge feel.
And be sure to properly break-in and maintain any high quality glove for optimal performance season after season.
