No more surprise encounters with those pesky animals roaming around!
But what are the odds of colliding with a deer in the first place? Better safe than sorry, right?
And with a guard, you are assured of optimal protection, so why not?
A Ranch Hand bumper weighs 250 lbs, while a deer guard weighs 145 lbs. A Ranch Hand Bumper is made of high-quality steel, whereas a guard combines steel and aluminum.
And that’s just a drop in the bucket, so let’s keep it moving!
A Quick Comparison Table
| Product Description | Ranch Hand Bumper | Deer Guard |
| Material Used | High-quality steel 12-gauge tubing | 14-gauge stainless steel and aluminum |
| Warranty Term | One-year | Limited lifetime |
| Design and Build | Concave structure Single-piece welded Six LED lights | Frame-mounted Wrap-around loop design |
| Quality | Fairly good | Excellent |
| Performance | Moderate | Top-tier |
| Installation | Complex | Simple |
| Weight | 250 lbs | 145 lbs |
| Cost | $1630 | $912-$1889 |
In-depth Differences Between Ranch Hand Bumper And Deer Guard
- Material Used
A Ranch Hand bumper is made from high-quality and super-dense diamond plate black steel.
It has a 12-gauge tubing and punch plate that makes it remarkably strong and durable.
On top of that, the bumper is constructed using 3/16-inch-thick smooth steel and schedule 40 piping, meaning this is a tool that you can rest easy knowing that it will serve you for generations.
On the other side, a deer guard is made of highly durable steel and a touch of aluminum. The upside of this combo is that it makes the guard light enough not to weigh down your vehicle.
Additionally, this tool is designed using 14-gauge stainless steel and covered in a semi-gloss black powder finish, which creates an appealing appearance for your vehicle.
Also Read: Differences Between Ranch Hand Legend And Summit Bumpers.
- Warranty Term
It’s necessary to always look at the warranty feature, especially in an investment as expensive as a deer protector bumper.
A Ranch Hand bumper provides limited one-year coverage, warranting the product free from defects in components and craft. And not just that! The cover includes the cost of the tool.
On the flip side, a deer guard offers limited lifetime coverage upon the date of purchase that covers parts and the finish. With this one, you don’t need to be concerned about the failures that would come as the manufacturer takes liability.
- Design and Build
Ranch Hand bumpers are one of the largest tools built for ¾ tons and much bigger trucks. Moreover, it contains six LED lights that provide an excellent looming image to the deer, thus leading it to move out of the way of an approaching vehicle.
Also, the bumper features a concave design that immensely improves its rigidity, lowering any trauma resulting from the impact.
And last but not least, it is constructed using a one-piece fully welded design that provides unbeatable strength and increases the lifespan. There’s minimal chance of bolts loosening or rusting.
Inversely, a deer guard contains a frame-mounted structure that gives excellent resistance to impact and promotes longevity.
Most of all, it has a wrap-around loop design to ensure the headlights are completely covered such that the front part is not shielded from damage.
- Quality
Regarding quality, a guard is steps ahead. It’s made of top-tier components that allow the tool to hold up exceptionally well to a deer.
The solid construction optimally amplifies the strength, doing far more than protecting the middle part of your truck.
You can mount it from four angles to give a fixed fit and eliminates the annoying noise that most bumpers have.
Be sure to confirm whether it’s made of steel and how well it fits on your vehicle if you want the best quality.
Conversely, a Range Hand bumper is of fairly good quality. At least you are assured that there is no day that you’ll be stranded on the road with a broken radiator or front end. That much I can guarantee you!
- Performance
Every vehicle deserves a good bumper that is strong enough to protect against unforeseen situations while giving it a distinguished, stylish look.
A Ranch Hand bumper understands the assignment. This equipment stands up perfectly to whatever life throws at it due to its heavy-duty construction process and materials.
The drawback I’ve observed with this bumper is that it tends to strain the front end of a car due to its weight. But other than that, this equipment is a moderately-performing one.
Contrarily, a deer guard offers excellent performance. Can we first give it a loud applause since it puts zero pressure on a car? I’ve yet to get to the best part!
No weight hangs on the front; thus, a deer has no chance of wrecking it.
- Installation Process
Ranch Hand bumper can be complex and a little cumbersome to install, and here’s why. Since the equipment is massive and heavy, it is usually shipped using truck freight, and lifting it can be incredibly difficult.
This is a process you don’t want to do alone to avoid causing bodily injuries. You should get some professional personnel to assist you in setting up the bumper accordingly.
However, let’s give credit where it’s due. Ranch Hand bumper comes with comprehensive instructions to help you through. Also, there is a no-drill on the mounting kit to ease the process.
Do you prioritize an effortless installation? If you’re strong enough, you can set up a deer guard yourself.
But if you want to be done quicker and sooner, getting another set of hands will do that for you. This tool is more interesting; no tweaking, grinding, or drilling is needed.
- Weight
A Ranch Hand Bumper is heavy-duty equipment that keeps you and the vehicle safe.
However, it might not be the lightest tool as it weighs 250 lbs. But that is to be expected since this brand is built using extremely heavy components and is purposed for heavy tasks. Plus, it has extremely good longevity.
In contrast, deer guards are super lightweight, weighing just about 145 lbs. Another plus of this life-saving protector is that it is incredibly easy to operate and fold.
Therefore, if you are after a light guard for your car that is effortless to handle, the product you seek is right in front of you.
- Cost
An investment as expensive as a bumper requires much-given thought because you want to see your money put into a good place. No one wants to spend thousands of dollars on a shoddy machine!
To land yourself a Ranch Hand bumper, you’ll need to spend $1630.
On the flip side, the cost of a deer guard depends on the quality and type you’re going for.
The most expensive is about $1889, while the cheapest costs $912.
My favorite part about the guard is that it gives you the flexibility to choose the tool based on the cost that you find most convenient.
Additionally, the deer guard is the best option if you are under budget.
But if you are okay with spending a standard amount of cash, a Ranch Hand bumper is a good pick.
Which Guard Is Better?
If you’re still hesitant, I understand. Again, a guard costs a lot of money, and you want to be sure you’re making the right investment, right?
Pause for a second and imagine the extra cost, energy, and time it would cost you if, by bad luck, a deer hits your unguarded vehicle.
Now that we’re on the same page, both tools are remarkable. A Ranch Hand bumper has more features, is good quality, and is superbly durable. Oppositely, a deer guard has excellent performance, offers more price flexibility, and is simple to install.
Also Read: Differences Between Ranch Hand And Steelcraft Bumpers.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, with no doubt. A bumper guard installed on your vehicle massively protects against any absorption of impacts into the cabin section after a collision head-on-head. However, different brands offer different levels of protection; thus, you have to ensure you get the right tool for the best results.
A Ranch Hand Bumper is a tough tool specially engineered and designed to shield your car and also family from both predictable and non-predictable situations that might come your way. Built using high-quality and durable components, this equipment provides immeasurable protection and lasts longer than expected.
Having a brush guard is one of the most effective ways to handle an event of a deer. All you need to do is set up the tool at your car’s front frame and then wrap it around the headlights and hood.
It depends on your need. If you are after low-speed protection against accidental encounters and wildlife impacts, then deer guard is the way to go. Nonetheless, avoid the deer guard if you need extra protection in high speed, utmost pedestrian safety, and high-impact accidents.
Final Verdict
I’m positive that you fully share my thoughts that a guard is a must-have asset for the safety of you and your motor. And from the Ranch Hand bumper and deer guard comparison, it’s obvious that you have two awesome choices to pick from.
A Ranch Hand bumper is an excellent quality if you want the greatest durability and want more features in your machine. But overall, a deer guard is our clear winner!
The performance is exceptional, it has a broad range of prices, installing is a breeze, and the quality is unmatched.
