Twill Tonneau Covers are made of a combination of cotton and polyester material. But Vinyl Tonneau Covers have Marine-grade material. Twill is heavier and has more weight capacity than vinyl due to its thicker and heavy-duty material.
Are you confused about choosing between a twill and vinyl Tonneau cover?
You might be wondering which soft cover is better, right? Picking a particular option requires you first to learn everything in detail. Keep scrolling to learn about their primary differences.
A Quick Comparison Table
| Specifications | Twill Tonneau Cover | Vinyl Tonneau Cover |
| Material | A combination of cotton and polyester | Marine-grade material |
| Weight | Heavier | Lightweight |
| Loading Capacity | 400 lbs to 600 lbs | 250 lbs to 300 lbs |
| Opening Styles | Limited opening styles | More opening styles |
| Special Benefit | Exceptional Weather tight seal | A durable layer of defense for waterproof protection |
| Durability | Higher | Slightly lower |
| Price | Expensive | Affordable |
Key Differences BetweenTwill And Vinyl Tonneau Cover
- Material
Twill Tonneau cover is made of a combination of cotton and polyester material.
This heavy-duty material is thicker. It doesn’t prone to fading issues.
The color remains in its original condition for a long time.
Extreme weather conditions will not cause any harm to it.
Contradictorily, a Vinyl Tonneau cover is mainly made of Marine-grade material.
The product can show reliable performance in water or wet environments.
It can also sustain its color and suppleness for a long time.
Also Read: Differences Between Lomax Matte Black And Urethane Finish Tonneau Cover.
- Weight
The average weight of a Tonneau cover can be anywhere from 30lbs to 110 lbs. It depends on the material, size, added hardware, and some other factors.
Both materials-based covers are soft-type. But twill is heavier than vinyl because it is made of a combination of two materials. Heavier Tonneau covers provide increased protection.
But the flexibility might be slightly compromised, unlike a lightweight cover. However, both options are made from dedicated quality material to protect the vehicle.
- Loading Capacity
A Tonneau cover has a loading capacity of 200 lbs to 3000 lbs depending on its material, construction type, and many other aspects. Hard Tonneau covers have more weight enduring capacity than softer ones.
Twill Tonneau covers can handle 400 lbs to 600 lbs. It varies due to the type of hardware installed along with the cover. A heavy-duty strap system and integrated clip will support the cover to handle more loads.
In opposition, Vinyl Tonneau covers can handle up to 250 lbs to 300 lbs. They are usually the softest option. You can’t rely on them to handle too much weight. Otherwise, their physical properties will be compromised.
- Opening Styles
Twill Tonneau covers are available in some opening styles, such as folded, hinged, and retracted. Hinged covers come in handy if you want to keep them in an open position to load and unload items effortlessly.
But Vinyl Tonneau covers are available in almost any opening style, such as snaps, roll-up, one-piece solid cover, hinged, retracted, etc. Roll-up covers provide the benefit of partially opening the cover without a fixed amount of space.
- Special Benefit
One of the remarkable benefits of Twill Tonneau covers is their top-quality weather-tight seal.
Their combined materials have thicker pores, preventing the outside air from entering the truck bed.
Apart from protecting the load, it will ensure improved aerodynamics.
On the other hand, Vinyl Tonneau covers have a durable layer of defense for waterproof protection.
They are highly water resistant. Keeping the truck bed fully dry during rainfall is easygoing. Whether snow or rain, the cover can prevent the vast majority of water or snow from going inside the truck’s bed.
- Durability
The average lifespan of a high-quality Tonneau cover can be more than ten years. But cheap quality Twill Tonneau usually covers can last 3 to 5 years.
Compared to Vinyl Tonneau covers, twill will last longer due to its thicker and heavy-duty materials.
But its longevity often depends on the additional hardware used. Plus, extreme weather conditions will cause wear and tear.
Both Twill and Vinyl Tonneau covers are soft-type. You can’t expect them to last as long as hard-type Tonneau covers.
However, your maintenance approach and installation method will also affect its durability too.
- Price
A Tonneau cover can cost anywhere from $200 to $1,000. It varies depending on the material, brand, hardware option, type, and other factors.
Due to their heavy-duty material, Twill Tonneau covers are slightly more expensive than Vinyl Tonneau covers.
But a few brands may have Vinyl Tonneau covers because of the premium quality hardware and additional features.
For example, it may have Locking clamps for simple installation without drilling. Many covers have customized options to fit the trucks’ back area perfectly. High-quality coating on the cover surface will make the unit more costly.
Which Tonneau Cover’s Material Is Best For You?
So, you already got a precise detail about both materials-based Tonneau covers, right?
But, it is now time to curve up the discussion into one factor. Which one should you choose?
If you prefer an affordable Tonneau cover and aren’t in extremely harsh weather conditions, a Vinyl Tonneau cover will not be the wrong choice.
But, if you plan to use a Tonneau cover for at least five years and live in an extremely rainy or snowy area, nothing can match better than a Twill Tonneau cover.
Due to thicker pores, its water resistance properties are better than Vinyl Tonneau covers. A minimal amount of water or snow will enter the truck bed.
Also Read: Fas-Top Or Softopper Topper?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Twill Tonneau Covers are made of a combination of cotton and polyester material. But Vinyl Tonneau Covers have Marine-grade material.
Vinyl Tonneau covers are an excellent choice for their water resistance, flexibility, and affordability.
Diamondback Covers are one of the strongest tonneau covers as they can handle as much as 2,000-pound weight.
The anti-theft design locks of a painted one-piece tonneau cover make them one of the most secure. You can’t open the tailgate unless the cover is unlocked while being in the upright condition.
Wrapping Up
So, which option have you decided to choose between Twill and Vinyl Tonneau cover? Both material-based Tonneau covers have their own pros and cons.
Twill Tonneau covers are a better choice for increased protection and long-lasting durability. But you can pick Vinyl Tonneau covers if you prefer an affordable option.
