If you’re in the market for a high-end cooler, chances are you’ve heard of both Coho and YETI. These two brands dominate the roto-molded cooler space, with passionate fans on both sides of the debate over which is better.
In this in-depth comparison, we’ll examine the key differences between Coho and YETI across a number of categories to help you decide which cooler is the right one for your needs and budget.
We’ll look at factors like ice retention, build quality, features, sizing and capacity options, cost, warranty coverage, and more.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Coho | YETI |
| Ice Retention | 6-8 days | 7-10 days |
| Build Quality | Roto-molded, plastic hardware | Roto-molded, rubber hardware |
| Size Options | 35-100 quarts | 20-350 quarts |
| Weight | Comparable | Comparable |
| Features | Integrated basket, easy-close latches | More colors, built-in bottle opener |
| Cost | $$-$$$ | $$$-$$$$ |
| Warranty | Lifetime | 5 years |
| Availability | Direct mostly | Widespread |
Key Differences Between Coho And YETI Coolers
- Ice Retention
The most important job of any cooler is keeping things cold, so ice retention is a major consideration when comparing high-end brands.
Both YETI and Coho deliver excellent ice retention thanks to their roto-molded construction.
This manufacturing process involves rotating the cooler body while plastic is molded around it, resulting in thicker, more durable walls that resist heat transfer.
In multiple ice retention challenges, Coho coolers performed nearly on par with the equivalent YETI models. For example, a 55 quart Coho cooler held ice for 6 days, while a similar YETI held ice for just over 7 days.
For most users’ needs, this is a negligible difference.
The takeaway: both Coho and YETI are insulation powerhouses, capable of keeping ice frozen for days at a time. For extended off-grid adventures, you really can’t go wrong with either brand in terms of keeping drinks and food chilled.
Slight Edge: YETI
Also Read: Differences Between PURE Drinkware And YETI Tumblers.
- Build Quality
YETI set the standard for premium cooler construction, and Coho closely follows suit. Both brands rely on roto-molded construction for enhanced durability and insulation. The coolers feature thick walls and a rugged build that can take some serious abuse.
There are some differences in design elements worth noting. YETI lids have a rubber gasket that snaps tightly into place to create an airtight seal, while Coho lids rests on top of the cooler body without a gasket. YETI also uses heavy-duty rubber latches compared to Coho’s plastic latches.
When it comes to handles, Coho offers rope handles on most models while YETI has rope plus molded-in handles. YETI’s non-slip feet are fixed while Coho’s are adjustable.
Overall, while Coho loses a few points for some slightly cheaper hardware, both coolers are extremely solid and can handle being hauled around even the toughest terrain. For most users, either will provide many years of reliable performance.
Slight Edge: YETI
- Features
YETI set the bar high when it comes to features, but Coho matches or exceeds them in some areas.
One big advantage of Coho is the inclusion of a basket in most coolers.
This provides handy storage up top for items you want quick access to like keys, phones, or snacks.
Coho’s dual-locking latches are also easier for most people to open and close than YETI’s single-pull latches.
YETI offers more color customization options and some higher-end features like a built-in bottle opener and ruler on the lid. All current YETI models also include Vortex drain systems for quick water removal, while only some Coho coolers have this.
Both brands offer accessories like baskets, tie-down kits, and more that allow you to customize your cooler. But Coho’s offerings are more limited since they are a newer company.
For features and customizability, YETI still has a slight edge. But Coho covers the basics very well at a more affordable price point.
Slight Edge: YETI
- Sizing and Capacity
YETI dominates when it comes to size options, offering a huge range from the compact Roadie 20 up to the massive 350. Coho’s lineup is much more limited, focused primarily on 55 to 75 quart capacities.
Here is how the size options stack up between the two brands:
Coho Sizes:
- 35 quart
- 55 quart
- 75 quart
- 100 quart
YETI Sizes:
- Roadie 20
- Tundra 35
- Tundra 45
- Tundra 65
- Tundra 75
- Tundra 105
- Tundra 110
- Tundra 125
- Tundra 160
- Tundra 210
- Tundra 250
- Tundra 350
YETI also offers hard and soft-sided backpack coolers while Coho does not currently have a backpack model.
If you need an ultra-portable cooler or a massive 350-quart behemoth, only YETI has you covered. But Coho’s mid-sized offerings still work great for most activities.
Edge: YETI
- Cost
Here’s where Coho really starts to stand out as a cooler alternative. Across comparable sizes, Coho consistently runs $50-$100 cheaper than YETI.
For example, the Coho 75 quart retails for around $350 while the Yeti Tundra 75 goes for $450 – a $100 price difference. You’ll see similar savings on the other matching sizes.
Of course, cost isn’t everything. But for shoppers trying to balance performance with their budget, Coho delivers huge value. You still get excellent ice retention and a rugged build, just with less dent to your wallet upfront.
Edge: Coho
Also Read: Is YETI Better Than Hooked Cooler?
- Warranty
You want peace of mind that your cooler investment is protected long-term. Both YETI and Coho offer strong warranties, but once again, Coho comes out a bit ahead.
Coho offers a limited lifetime warranty covering defects in materials and workmanship. YETI now offers a 5 year limited warranty, after recently reducing down from their previous lifetime policy.
For the first 5 years, you’re equally covered. But beyond that, Coho has the advantage for giving customers that true lifetime guarantee on their purchase.
Edge: Coho
- Availability
As one of the leading brands in the industry, YETI has much wider availability both online and in physical retail stores.
Coho is primarily sold direct-to-consumer through their own website, with just limited availability on Amazon and other third-party marketplaces.
If you like having the option to walk into a store and pick up a cooler off the shelf, YETI is likely the simpler option.
But Coho’s direct model does allow them to offer lower pricing since there’s no retail markup.
Edge: YETI
- Customer Service
By selling primarily online direct, Coho maintains a very responsive customer service team available via phone, email or chat. They receive positive reviews on quickly handling any warranty issues or concerns.
Yeti also has knowledgeable customer service staff and representatives active on forums ready to help customers. Their presence across retailers likely makes scaling service a bigger challenge compared to a smaller operation like Coho, but overall satisfaction appears high with both brands.
For customer service response and satisfaction, this one is a tie. Both Coho and YETI aim to please their customers.
Edge: Tie
- Aesthetics
Beauty is in the eye of the cooler holder here. Yeti offers far more color and graphic options to customize the look of your cooler. But Coho’s simple, straightforward aesthetic has its appeal too.
For some, Coho’s rope handles and wood-accented lids give the coolers a more refined, classy look compared to YETI’s industrial vibe.
In terms of colors, YETI has the upper hand. But a Coho cooler still looks handsome on the back of boat or truck in classic white/tan.
Slight Edge: YETI
Also Read: Is ORCA Better Than Grizzly Cooler?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Coho is considered one of the top brands for high-end roto-molded coolers. They produce excellent ice retention paired with a durable, rugged build. Their coolers have proven performance on par with more expensive competitors.
Based on ice retention tests and construction quality, Coho is the top brand that consistently matches up with YETI in performance. Other brands like RTIC and Pelican also compete as alternatives, but may cut more corners.
Very few brands definitively beat YETI in terms of ice retention or build quality. Brands like Yetti, Pelican, Canyon, and Orca are all comparable. But no major brand clearly outperforms YETI by a wide margin across the board.
You can expect 6-8 days of ice retention in a Coho cooler, depending on size. Well-constructed Coho coolers keep ice just as long as equivalently sized YETI models in most tests. For extended camping trips or long weekends, they have outstanding insulation.
The Verdict: Should You Buy A Coho or YETI Cooler?
At the end of the day, you really can’t go wrong investing in either brand. YETI arguably still leads in prestige, brand awareness and size selection. But Coho delivers nearly equal performance at a more affordable price point.
Here are the key factors to consider when choosing between the two brands:
Buy a YETI If You…
- Want the most size options, including massive 350 or tiny Roadie models
- Appreciate YETI’s premium brand cache and name recognition
- Like bold color and graphic customization options
- Value maximum heavy duty ruggedness for extreme, rough conditions
Buy a Coho If You…
- Want to save $50-$100+ vs the comparable YETI
- Like the included basket for organizational convenience
- Primarily need a 55-75 quart mid-sized cooler
- Prefer Coho’s simplified, elegant aesthetic
- Appreciate their direct purchasing model
For most people debating between Coho and YETI coolers, Coho represents the smarter buy that delivers nearly equal performance for less money. But YETI still holds the advantage for those wanting niche sizes or the leading name brand clout.
Whichever you choose, either of these high-end coolers are built to last a lifetime out on the water or in the backcountry. You really can’t go wrong with Coho or YETI for keeping drinks icy cold at the tailgate or on your outdoor adventures.
