Both Tethrd and Trophyline have been synonymous with reliability in the saddle-hunting industry. While both are popular, the differences mainly come down to their sizes, comfort levels, durability, and pricing.
Saddle hunting has been prevalent in the US lately. As a hunter, you will always want to go deeper into the wilderness and unburden yourself of the noise and weight that comes with hunting.
Below I have compared two of the best hunting saddle brands, Tethrd and Trophyline. The comparison should point out the better fit for your hunting needs.
Quick Comparison Table
| Specifications | Tethrd | Trophyline |
| Range of products | Saddles, Platforms, Saddle kits, Climbing tools, Accessories, Ropes & connections, Apparel | Tree saddles, Platforms and sticks, Packs and bags, Bundles, Rope and carabineers, Saddle accessories, Hunting Accessories, Apparel |
| Size options | Medium, large, and extra large | Large and XL |
| Comfortability | Decent comfortability | More comfortable |
| Weight capacity | 300 lbs., more durable | 300 lbs., decent durability |
| Cost | More expensive | Less expensive |
| Warranty and return | 1-year warranty and 30-day return without shipping fee | 1-year warranty and 30-day return with the shipping fee |
| Availability | More available | Less available |
Key Differences Between Tethrd And Trophyline
- Range of Products
One of the most significant differences between these brands is their range of products.
While Tethrd and Trophyline are famous for their saddles, they also have other products to complete your hunting setup.
There are several standard products like saddle kits, ropes, carabiners, apparel, and accessories that both brands sell.
However, Trophyline also offers sticks, bags, and packs, unlike Tethrd.
Also Read: Differences Between Latitude Method 2 And Cruzr XC Hunting Saddles.
- Size
The sale size is essential if you want a comfortable user experience in a long hunting session. Both Tethrd and Trophyline offer multiple sizes to fit your need.
However, if you want a size variety to try out, Tethrd offers more options. It currently offers three sizes, medium (26″-34″), large (34″-38″), and extra-large (38″-44″). On the other hand, Trophyline has a limited size range with two sizes, large (up to 36”) and XL (36″-42″).
- Comfortability
Saddle hunting involves hanging from a tree for hours without movement. In that situation, comfort is everything for an exciting hunting experience. There are a lot of saddles out there that cuts the blood circulation in your legs and make it tough to move.
In that regard, both Tethrd and Trophyline saddle kits are pretty comfortable. However, users of Trophyline kits have said it offers better comfort with loose leg straps that promote leg blood circulation.
- Weight Capacity And Durability
One of the best parts of a hunting saddle is that it makes carrying weight much more accessible.
However, each saddle out there has a weight limit. In this case, both Tethrd and Trophyline saddles have a weight capacity of 300 lbs.
However, the higher main structure weight capacity of 6000 lbs. and a bridge weight capacity of 7700 lbs. puts Tethrd ahead. Tethrd also uses lighter, abrasion, and UV-resistant materials to offer better durability than Trophyline.
- Cost
Saddle kits or related accessories aren’t something we buy every day. So, before you purchase, you need to know which brand offers better value. Regarding pricing, Trophyline has the upper hand over Tethrd with more affordable gear.
However, what I appreciate about both brands is that they offer military and first responder discounts.
- Warranty and return
If you look at the construction of a saddle kit, nothing technical can become faulty over the years. However, Tethrd and Trophyline offer their customers a one-year warranty for manufacturer’s defects.
Also, if you haven’t used the sale yet, you can return both brands’ products within the first 30 days of purchase with a money-back guarantee. One good thing about Trophyline is that they cover the return shipping fee too, which Tethrd doesn’t.
- Availability
Availability is a minor concern you might face with both brands regarding inventory and shipping. According to the information from various forums and users, Tethrd has a slower inventory than Trophyline.
However, Tethrd makes up for that with international shipping, unlike Trophyline. You can contact Tethrd for an exact shipping quote.
Which Saddle Brand Will Be Better For You?
At the end of the comparison, both Tethrd and Trophyline look very appealing, with their fair share of strengths and weaknesses. There is no clear winner between these brands, and the better suit will be subjective.
If you are after durability, more sizing options, and availability, Tethrd is the better option. On the other hand, if you are after affordability, product variety, and warranty policy, Trophyline is the ideal brand for you.
Watch this video to understand why.
Also Read: Titan Vs. Summit Goliath Climbing Tree Stand.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
One of the best aspects of Trophyline is that all their products are 100% USA-made. It might not seem like a big deal, but you’ll surely notice the difference in quality, longevity, and precise finish. Their manufacturing plant is located in Aurora, Ohio.
Like Trophyline, Tethrd is another complete USA-made hunting saddle and accessories brand. Everything is done on US soil with fine craftsmanship, whether it’s manufacturing, designing, or just assembly. Tethrd’s manufacturing location is in Nebraska.
The first step of putting a saddle on a tree is familiarizing yourself with the different parts. You can set up at the ground levels, a few inches up from the ground, to practice. Then tie in your tether at your comfortable height. When the tether is tied, you can attach the saddle and try different leaning and sitting positions for utmost comfort.
Final Words
That’s a wrap for today. I hope my comparison between Tethrd and Trophyline will help you determine your better-suited choice. More than ever, people are taking hunting as a hobby, increasing the use of saddle hunting kits.
If you have been to saddle hunting before, you should know that it can get exhausting without proper gear. Luckily, both Tethrd and Trophyline brands offer the safest, quietest, and most mobile saddles and gears.
You have to get your priorities straight and go for a brand that suits your need.
Thank you for your comparison between Tethrd and Trophy line saddles. i am in the beginning stages and researching both products. I am an avid bowhunter from Pa and as I get older I am looking to venture deeper into the woods to get away from people and hunt bigger and more quality bucks. So being mobile is important to me. I really like the tethrd i think they company does a really good job making their products and so does trophy line as well. I am stopping by a local retailer this week so i can finally take out of the box to inspect it and try one on. When I hunt i hunt long and i want to be comfortable and the ease of climbing and being able shoot at 360 degrees is awesome, maybe not in all circumstances but the opportunity is there. Thank you Again1