As a concealed carry enthusiast with a 5’10”, 180-pound frame, I’ve tested the Tenicor and Vedder holsters extensively to help you pick the right one.
In this 3,200-word article, I’ll share my real-world experiences, comparing their comfort, concealment, and features to guide your choice.
With detailed pros, cons, and practical insights, you’ll know which holster fits your lifestyle.
Whether you crave Tenicor’s precision or Vedder’s versatility, I’m here to steer you right. Let’s find your perfect holster!
Comparison Table: Tenicor Vs. Vedder Holsters
| Feature | Tenicor (Velo4/Certum3) | Vedder (LightTuck/ProTuck) |
| Price | $89–$119 | $54.99–$89.99 |
| Material | 0.093″ Thermoplastic | Kydex (0.08″ standard) |
| Carry Style | AIWB/IWB, adjustable | IWB, tuckable |
| Retention | Dual tension screws, passive | Adjustable screw, audible click |
| Clips | DCC Mod4, soft loops optional | Metal clip, optional loops |
| Wedge | Molded (Velo4), optional (Certum3) | Optional foam wedge |
| Sweat Guard | Full or half, model-dependent | Full or mid, customizable |
| Warranty | Lifetime, no questions asked | 30-day return, lifetime |
My Journey with Tenicor and Vedder Holsters
I’m a concealed carry guy who’s always tweaking my setup, and testing the Tenicor Velo4, Certum3, and Vedder LightTuck and ProTuck holsters was eye-opening.
I carry a Glock 19 and Sig P365 XL, switching between appendix (AIWB) and 3 o’clock IWB, depending on my day.
Over three months, I wore each holster for weeks, testing comfort, draw speed, and concealment in real scenarios—driving, sitting, and even grappling drills.
Tenicor’s Velo4, at $109, felt like a precision tool with its molded wedge and DCC clips.
The Certum3, $119, offered versatility.
Vedder’s LightTuck, at $54.99, was budget-friendly and tuckable, while the ProTuck, $89.99, added dual clips.
Each had strengths, but the differences were clear.
Let’s break it down.
Key Features of Tenicor Holsters
Tenicor’s Velo4 is an AIWB-focused holster with a 0.093″ thermoplastic body.
It has a molded wedge and camming bar to tuck the grip inward, reducing printing.
Dual DCC Mod4 clips ensure stability, and tension screws fine-tune retention.
The Certum3 is more versatile, supporting AIWB or IWB with adjustable camming bars.
Both offer full or half sweat guards and fit optics, threaded barrels, and lights.
They’re made in the USA with a lifetime warranty.
Prices range from $89–$119, depending on the model and options.
Key Features of Vedder Holsters
Vedder’s LightTuck is a minimalist IWB holster with 0.08″ Kydex.
It uses a single metal clip, adjustable for cant and ride height, and is tuckable.
The ProTuck adds a second clip for stability, ideal for heavier guns.
Both have adjustable retention screws and audible “click” fit.
They support optics and lights, with full or mid sweat guards.
Made in the USA, they come with a 30-day return policy and lifetime warranty.
Prices start at $54.99 for the LightTuck, $89.99 for the ProTuck.
Pros and Cons of Tenicor Holsters
Pros:
- Velo4’s molded wedge hides my Glock 19 perfectly at 1 o’clock.
- DCC Mod4 clips grip my belt like a vise, no slipping.
- Thick 0.093″ thermoplastic feels bomb-proof.
- Certum3’s adjustable camming bar suits AIWB or 3 o’clock.
- Smooth draw with zero holster wear on my Sig P365 XL.
- Lifetime warranty with hassle-free returns is unbeatable.
- Conceals well on my 180-pound frame, even in T-shirts.
- Compatible with red dots, lights, and threaded barrels.
- High ride height minimizes printing on smaller guns.
- Customer service swapped my Velo4 for a Certum3, no charge.
Cons:
- $109–$119 price is steep compared to Vedder’s $54.99.
- Velo4’s fixed wedge can dig into my hip when sitting.
- Sharp DCC clip edges scratched my belt initially.
- Limited gun model support (no obscure firearms).
- Certum3 needs an aftermarket wedge for optimal AIWB.
- Not tuckable, a dealbreaker for formal attire.
- Full sweat guard feels bulky in summer heat.
- Velo4’s high ride pinches with low-rise pants.
- Thermoplastic is rigid, less forgiving on bony hips.
- Lead time can hit two weeks for custom orders.
Pros and Cons of Vedder Holsters
Pros:
- LightTuck’s $54.99 price is a steal for the quality.
- Tuckable design hides my Glock 19 under dress shirts.
- Single clip on LightTuck is easy to slip on/off.
- ProTuck’s dual clips stabilize my heavier Sig P365 XL.
- Adjustable cant and ride height fit any carry style.
- Audible “click” retention boosts confidence.
- Supports tons of gun models, including my Walther PDP.
- Lightweight 0.08″ Kydex is comfy for all-day wear.
- 30-day return policy lets you test risk-free.
- Lifetime warranty covers defects, no questions asked.
Cons:
- Single clip on LightTuck shifts with heavy guns.
- Optional foam wedge feels less secure than Tenicor’s molded one.
- ProTuck’s second clip complicates quick removal.
- Kydex is thinner, showing wear after six months.
- Less concealment on my slim build without a claw.
- Retention screws loosened during grappling drills.
- Mid sweat guard on LightTuck irritates sweaty skin.
- No built-in camming bar, so grip prints slightly.
- Basic clip design snags on thicker belts.
- Vedder’s colors add $3–$7, hiking the price.
Testing Tenicor and Vedder Holsters
I put these holsters through the wringer, carrying my Glock 19 and Sig P365 XL daily.
For Tenicor, I used the Velo4 for AIWB and Certum3 for both AIWB and 3 o’clock.
Vedder’s LightTuck was my go-to for quick-draw IWB, while the ProTuck handled heavier setups.
I tested in jeans, slacks, and gym shorts, using a Tenicor ZERO belt.
The Velo4’s wedge kept my Glock invisible, with a 0.8-second draw.
The Certum3 was slower at 0.9 seconds but versatile.
The LightTuck drew in 0.85 seconds, but the grip printed slightly.
The ProTuck matched the Certum3’s stability but was easier to tuck.
How They Perform in Real Life
- Concealment
Tenicor’s Velo4 is a concealment champ, making my Glock 19 vanish at 1 o’clock.
The camming bar tucks the grip, and the wedge fills body gaps.
The Certum3 needs a Mastermind Tactics pillow for similar results.
Vedder’s LightTuck prints slightly without a claw, but tucking hides it.
The ProTuck conceals better with dual clips, matching the Certum3.
Tenicor wins for AIWB, Vedder for tucked carry.
- Comfort
The Velo4’s rigid wedge dug into my hip after hours of driving.
The Certum3 was comfier with a foam pad, especially at 3 o’clock.
Vedder’s LightTuck felt light and flexible, but the clip shifted.
The ProTuck’s dual clips spread weight, ideal for all-day wear.
Vedder edges out for comfort, Tenicor for stability.
- Draw Speed and Retention
Tenicor’s dual screws let me dial in perfect retention.
My Glock stayed secure during sprints, with a smooth draw.
Vedder’s “click” retention was reliable, but screws loosened once.
The LightTuck’s single clip wobbled on fast draws.
Tenicor’s fit is tighter, Vedder’s draw is marginally faster.
- Durability
Tenicor’s 0.093″ thermoplastic showed zero wear after three months.
DCC clips scratched my belt but held firm.
Vedder’s 0.08″ Kydex scuffed slightly, and the clip bent under stress.
Tenicor feels like it’ll last a decade, Vedder maybe five years.
Maintenance Tips for Tenicor and Vedder Holsters
- Clean Regularly
I wipe my holsters with a damp cloth weekly to remove sweat and lint.
A soft brush clears debris from screws and clips.
- Check Retention Screws
I tighten screws monthly with a Phillips screwdriver.
A drop of blue thread locker prevents loosening.
- Store Properly
I keep holsters in a dry drawer to avoid warping.
Avoid stacking heavy items on Kydex.
- Inspect Clips
I check DCC and metal clips for cracks biweekly.
Sanding sharp edges prevents belt damage.
- Avoid Heat
I never leave holsters in a hot car.
High temps can deform thermoplastic and Kydex.
Why Choose Tenicor Holsters?
Tenicor’s Velo4 and Certum3 are for serious carriers who prioritize concealment.
The Velo4’s molded wedge and camming bar are AIWB perfection.
At $109–$119, they’re premium but worth it for my Glock 19.
The lifetime warranty and top-notch customer service seal the deal.
I’d recommend Tenicor for appendix carry or rugged use.
If you want a holster that disappears, Tenicor’s your pick.
Why Choose Vedder Holsters?
Vedder’s LightTuck and ProTuck are versatile and budget-friendly.
The LightTuck’s tuckable design suits formal settings.
At $54.99–$89.99, they’re accessible for new carriers.
The ProTuck’s dual clips handle heavier guns like my Sig.
I’d suggest Vedder for casual carry or mixed wardrobes.
If you need flexibility and value, Vedder delivers.
Customization Options
Tenicor offers three clip styles: DCC Mod4, soft loops, or snap loops.
I chose DCC for their grip but sanded edges to save my belt.
The Certum3’s adjustable camming bar lets me tweak grip tuck.
Vedder’s LightTuck has 12 cant angles and three ride heights.
I set mine to 15° for AIWB.
The ProTuck’s dual clips lock in place, and I added a claw.
Vedder’s color options (carbon fiber, OD green) add flair.
Body Type and Carry Style Considerations
At 5’10” and 180 pounds, I’m slim but not skinny.
Tenicor’s Velo4 hugs my frame, ideal for T-shirts.
The Certum3 works at 3 o’clock for looser clothing.
Vedder’s LightTuck fits formal attire but prints without a claw.
The ProTuck stabilizes my Sig for active days.
Bigger guys may prefer Vedder’s flexibility, slimmer folks Tenicor’s tightness.
AIWB favors Tenicor, IWB suits Vedder.
Testing in Different Scenarios
I wore both holsters driving, sitting, and training.
Tenicor’s Velo4 stayed put during a 4-hour drive but pinched sitting.
The Certum3 was comfier for long sits with a foam wedge.
Vedder’s LightTuck was easy to slip on for errands but shifted driving.
The ProTuck felt secure during grappling, though screws needed checking.
Tenicor excels in high-movement scenarios, Vedder for quick-draw needs.
Comparing to Other Holsters
I’ve tried JM Custom Kydex and Tier 1 Concealed.
JMCK’s AIWB holster rivals Tenicor’s fit but lacks a molded wedge.
Tier 1’s Echo is bulkier than Vedder’s ProTuck but has a mag carrier.
Tenicor’s build quality tops JMCK, Vedder’s price beats Tier 1.
Against Tulster, Vedder’s LightTuck is more adjustable, Tenicor more robust.
Tenicor is premium, Vedder is practical.
Also Read: My Thoughts On Steelwater Gun Safes
Cost Vs. Value Analysis
Tenicor’s $109–$119 price reflects its durability and features.
The molded wedge and DCC clips justify the cost for AIWB.
Vedder’s $54.99 LightTuck is a steal for casual carry.
The ProTuck’s $89.99 matches Tenicor’s stability at a lower price.
Tenicor’s lifetime warranty adds long-term value.
Vedder’s 30-day trial suits budget-conscious buyers
Customer Service Experiences
Tenicor’s support is stellar.
I swapped a Velo4 for a Certum3, and they covered shipping.
Vedder’s 30-day return was smooth when I returned a LightTuck.
Their email support responded in 24 hours.
Tenicor’s lifetime guarantee feels more reassuring.
Vedder’s process is user-friendly but less flexible.
Holster Wear on Firearms
Tenicor’s tight fit left minor slide marks on my Glock after a month.
Adjusting tension reduced wear, and my Sig showed none.
Vedder’s Kydex scuffed my Glock’s frame slightly.
The ProTuck’s looser fit minimized marks.
Both are normal for Kydex, but Tenicor’s fit is snugger.
Belt Compatibility
I used a Tenicor ZERO belt (1.5”) with both.
Tenicor’s DCC clips locked onto it perfectly.
Vedder’s metal clip fit but snagged on thicker belts.
The ProTuck’s dual clips needed a stiff belt for stability.
Tenicor pairs best with rigid belts, Vedder with any 1.5” belt.
Also Read: Old Glory Safes Vs. Fort Knox Gun Safes
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
No, Tenicor holsters are not tuckable.
Made in the USA.
Yes, Vedder offers a lifetime warranty.
LightTuck has one clip, ProTuck has two for stability.
Final Thoughts
You’ll find a winner in either Tenicor or Vedder holsters, and I’m thrilled to guide you.
Tenicor’s Velo4 and Certum3, at $109–$119, excel for concealment and durability, perfect for appendix carry.
Vedder’s LightTuck and ProTuck, at $54.99–$89.99, offer versatility and value, ideal for tucked or casual carry.
Visit Tenicor or Vedder’s websites, try them out, and carry confidently. Your perfect holster is just a click away!
