There are many similarities between Clam Nanook XL and Yukon XL. The only difference between the two tents is the size. Yukon XL is much larger than Clam Nanook XL in many aspects.
The Clam Nanook XL Thermal and Yukon XL comparative guide below discusses the similarities and differences between the two tents. By the end of the guide, you will know which tent to buy for your next fishing expedition. Let’s get started:
A Quick Comparison Table
| Specifications | Clam Nanook XL Thermal | Yukon XL |
| Set up size | L 92″ x W 61″ | L 93″ x W 63″ |
| Center Height | 69″ | 75″ |
| Pack Size with Seats | L 61″ x W 35″ x H 22″ | L 63″ x W 40″ x H 26″ |
| Weight | 76 Pounds | 104 Pounds |
| Fishing Area | L 56″ x W 59″ | L 55″ x W 59″ |
| Fishable Square Footage: | 23 square feet | 23 square feet |
| Seat Type | Deluxe Non-Padded | Deluxe Padded |
| Seat Weight Capacity | 300 lb. | 300 lb |
| Fabric | 900 Denier | 900 Denier |
| Floor Capability | Yes – Nanook XL removable floor | Yes – Yukon XL Removable Floor |
| Number of anglers | 2 | 2 |
| Warranty | One-year warranty against manufacturer’s defects | 3 Year warranty against manufacturer defects |
| Number of Doors | 3 | 3 |
| Number of Windows | 6 | 6 |
| Tow Rope Included | Yes | Yes |
| Insulated | Yes | Yes |
| Tub Size | L 61″ x W 35″ x H 8″ | L 63″ x W 40″ x H 13″ |
| Number of Vents | 2 | 2 |
Key Differences Between Clam Nanook XL Thermal And Yukon XL
- Weight
The weight of the tent determines how easy to pack and carry around. Yukon XL weighs 104 pounds which is way heavier than Clam Nanook, which weighs 76 pounds.
- Pack Size
The Yukon XL has a lot more interior volume than the Clam Nanook. This means that you can carry much more fishing gear and equipment. If you are pitching a tent close to the water, you can store your extra fishing gear right next to your tent.
- Space Saving
Yukon XL has a lot more interior volume than Clam Nanook XL.
The Yukon XL is also much wide, more comprehensive taller than Clam Nanook XL.
This means you get more space for your belongings and equipment in a broader area on both sides of the tent.
The taller height in the Yukon XL is also perfect for anglers taller than 6 feet.
- Seat Type
Clam Nanook XL Thermal has non-padded seats. This helps conserve a lot of weight. Yukon XL has removable padded seats, so you do not need to carry extra accessories.
For example, if you do not need the seats, you can leave them behind and still have a comfortable fishing experience.
- Insulation
Clam Nanook XL thermal is not insulated. One of the significant drawbacks of Camping in the winter is that no matter how good your tent is, it won’t keep you warm if it isn’t insulated.
The Yukon XL, on the other hand, has adequate insulation to keep you warm in cold temperatures.
- Securing Gear
Clam Nanook XL thermal does not have tie tie-downs in your gear. It also needs a storage pocket for your fishing gear which may become a problem when carrying extra equipment in the tent.
- Weatherproofing
Clam Nanook XL thermal is made from a 900 Denier fabric which is not waterproof. On the other hand, Yukon XL is made from a thicker material that offers waterproofing and extra protection against harsh weather conditions.
- Ease of Set Up
Setting up Clam Nanook XL is simple. The tent comes with a manual, and it o takes about 10 minutes to set up. On the other hand, Yukon XL is much more complex than Clam Nanook XL.
It does not have a manual and takes about 30-45 minutes to set up. This is due to the sheer size of the Yukon XL, which makes it much harder to fold and pack away correctly.
- US Fish and Wildlife Approved
The Yukon XL is approved by the US Fish and Wildlife department. This means that you can use the tent fishing in various places throughout the US without worrying about restrictions that you may encounter.
- Cost
Yukon XL, or the giant tent, costs more than Clam Nanook XL, or the smaller one.
- Warranty
Clam Nanook XL thermal comes with a one-year warranty against defects. On the other hand, Yukon XL has a three-year warranty.
Which Tent Is Better?
After reviewing all the information above, we agree that Nanook XL and Yukon XL are unique tents.
However, based on the features offered by Clam Nanook XL Thermal, we recommend that you consider it for your next fishing expedition.
Clam Nanook XL Thermal is the better choice because it has a lighter weight, larger fishing area, and more interior volume.
With the extra money you save on the Clam Nanook XL Thermal, you can purchase other accessories for your fishing trip. You get to enjoy an affordable fishing tent with great features.
Yukon XL offers better warranty coverage compared to Clam Nanook XL.
Also Read: Should You Get White Duck Or Kodiak Canvas Tent?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Nanook XL tents are water resistant but need to be waterproof. This means the tent will withstand light rain but cannot withstand heavy rain.
Nanook XL weighs around 76 pounds. This tent is too light, making it ideal for portability.
Yukon XL can be compared to other unique tents. This tent has advantages regarding the warranty and the seat types are padded.
Conclusion
Camping can be a great outdoor activity for thrill seekers. However, negotiating the tent and fishing poles inside the tent may be frustrating for some. The Nanook XL offers much better value for your money than the heavier Yukon XL.
However, if you are looking for a tent to fit extra seats, Yukon got to be your choice.
The comparison of Clam Nanook XL Thermal and Yukon XL tents discusses other differences and comparisons between the two tents.
