I’ve always been fascinated by full-size SUVs, those massive vehicles that promise space, power, and versatility for families, adventurers, and anyone needing to haul a lot of stuff. When it came time to choose between the Chevrolet Suburban and the GMC Yukon XL, I found myself weighing two giants in the automotive world.
Both are built by General Motors, share similar DNA, and cater to similar needs, yet they have distinct personalities. In this article, I’ll share my experience comparing these two SUVs, breaking down their features, pros, and cons to help you decide which one fits your lifestyle best.
Comparison Table: Chevrolet Suburban Vs. GMC Yukon XL
| Feature | Chevrolet Suburban | GMC Yukon XL |
|---|---|---|
| Starting MSRP | $63,276 | $68,788 |
| Cargo Space (Max) | 144.7 cu ft | 144.7 cu ft |
| Fuel Economy (City/Hwy) | 15/20 MPG (5.3L V8) | 16/20 MPG (5.3L V8) |
| Towing Capacity | Up to 8,300 lbs | Up to 8,400 lbs |
| Base Engine | 5.3L V8 (355 hp, 383 lb-ft) | 5.3L V8 (355 hp, 383 lb-ft) |
| Available Engines | 6.2L V8, 3.0L Turbo-Diesel | 6.2L V8, 3.0L Turbo-Diesel |
| Seating Capacity | Up to 9 | Up to 9 |
| Wheelbase | 134.1 inches | 134.1 inches |
| Length | 225.7 inches | 225.2 inches |
| Infotainment Screen | 17.7-inch touchscreen | 15-inch touchscreen |
| Reliability Rating | 9.1/10 (iSeeCars) | 9.0/10 (iSeeCars) |
| Safety Rating (NHTSA) | 4/5 Stars | 4/5 Stars |
My Experience With the Chevrolet Suburban
When I first slid into the driver’s seat of the 2025 Chevrolet Suburban, it felt like stepping into a command center.
The sheer size of this SUV is imposing, yet it’s surprisingly approachable.
The Suburban has been a staple in the automotive world since 1935, and its reputation for reliability and versatility precedes it.
Driving through my neighborhood, I noticed heads turning—there’s something about its bold stance that demands attention.
The interior is cavernous, with enough room to seat up to nine passengers comfortably, making it a dream for large families or group road trips.
The Suburban’s base 5.3L V8 engine delivers a robust 355 horsepower, which I found more than adequate for merging onto highways or towing my friend’s boat for a weekend getaway.
The available 6.2L V8, with 420 horsepower, felt like overkill for my daily needs but was a thrill when I pushed it on open roads.
The 3.0L Duramax Turbo-Diesel, with its 277 horsepower but hefty 460 lb-ft of torque, offered a different kind of power—smooth and efficient, especially for long hauls. I averaged about 15 MPG in the city and 20 on the highway with the 5.3L, which isn’t stellar but expected for a vehicle this size.
The 17.7-inch touchscreen infotainment system was a standout. It’s massive, responsive, and integrates seamlessly with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Navigating menus felt intuitive, and the system handled everything from music streaming to navigation with ease.
The Suburban’s cargo space—up to 144.7 cubic feet with the seats folded—was a game-changer. I loaded it up with camping gear, groceries, and even a bike without breaking a sweat. The third-row seats are spacious enough for adults, a rarity in SUVs, and the power-folding feature made transitions between passenger and cargo setups effortless.
Safety features like Forward collision Alert, Lane Keep Assist, and Rear Park Assist gave me confidence in tight parking lots and busy streets. The Suburban High Country trim, with its premium leather and heated everything, felt luxurious, though I noticed the base LS trim’s cloth seats were still comfortable and practical. My only gripe was the fuel economy—large SUVs guzzle gas, and the Suburban is no exception. But for those needing space and capability, it’s a small price to pay.
My Experience With the GMC Yukon XL
The 2025 GMC Yukon XL, on the other hand, brought a different flavor to the table. It’s the Suburban’s upscale cousin, with a focus on premium styling and refined details.
Driving the Yukon XL, I felt a touch of sophistication that the Suburban sometimes lacks. The Denali trim, in particular, with its chrome-heavy grille and 22-inch wheels, screamed luxury.
It’s the kind of vehicle that makes you feel like you’ve arrived, whether you’re pulling up to a campsite or a fancy restaurant.
The Yukon XL shares the same powertrains as the Suburban, so performance felt familiar. The 5.3L V8 was smooth for daily driving, while the 6.2L V8 in the Denali added a punchy, exhilarating edge.
I tested the diesel option, too, and appreciated its torque for towing—up to 8,400 pounds, slightly more than the Suburban’s 8,300. Fuel economy was marginally better at 16 MPG city and 20 MPG highway with the 5.3L, though I didn’t notice a significant difference in real-world driving.
The interior of the Yukon XL is where it tries to outshine the Suburban. The Denali Ultimate’s Woodland Mahogany leather and 16-way power front seats with massage functions made long drives feel like a spa day. The 15-inch touchscreen, while slightly smaller than the Suburban’s, was equally user-friendly and packed with Google built-in features.
Cargo space matches the Suburban’s 144.7 cubic feet, and I had no trouble fitting all my gear. The Yukon XL’s available Super Cruise, a hands-free driving system, was a highlight on highways, though it’s an expensive add-on.
What stood out most was the Yukon XL’s attention to detail. The LED headlamps, hands-free liftgate, and available Night Vision system added a tech-savvy edge. However, I found the base SLE trim less impressive, lacking some of the Suburban’s standard features like the larger touchscreen. The Yukon XL’s higher starting price also gave me pause—$68,788 compared to the Suburban’s $63,276. For those chasing luxury, the Yukon XL delivers, but it comes at a cost.
Read More: My Thoughts On BMW X7 Vs. Cadillac Escalade
Pros Of the Chevrolet Suburban
- Affordable Starting Price: The Suburban’s MSRP of $63,276 is significantly lower than the Yukon XL’s $68,788, making it a better value for budget-conscious buyers seeking similar performance and space.
- Class-Leading Cargo Space: With 41.5 cubic feet behind the third row and up to 144.7 cubic feet with seats folded, the Suburban offers unmatched utility for families or adventurers.
- Larger Infotainment Screen: The 17.7-inch touchscreen is one of the largest in its class, offering crisp visuals and seamless smartphone integration.
- Reliability Edge: iSeeCars rates the Suburban at 9.1/10 for reliability, slightly higher than the Yukon XL’s 9.0/10, giving me confidence in its long-term durability.
- More Trim Options: The Suburban offers six trims (LS, LT, RST, Z71, Premier, High Country), providing more flexibility to match your needs and budget compared to the Yukon XL’s five.
- Standard Features: Even the base LS trim includes a 17.7-inch touchscreen, wireless Apple CarPlay, and safety features like Forward Collision Alert, which aren’t always standard on the Yukon XL’s base model.
- Proven Legacy: As the longest-running nameplate in automotive history, the Suburban’s reputation for dependability and versatility is hard to beat.
The Suburban’s affordability and practicality make it a standout. I found the lower starting price a huge draw, especially since it doesn’t skimp on essentials like cargo space or tech. The 17.7-inch touchscreen was a joy to use, whether I was navigating winding roads or streaming music for my kids. Reliability is a big deal for me, and the Suburban’s slight edge in iSeeCars’ ratings gave me peace of mind. The variety of trims meant I could choose a rugged Z71 for off-road adventures or a plush High Country for city cruising. It’s a versatile SUV that doesn’t demand a premium price for premium features.
Cons Of the Chevrolet Suburban
- Fuel Economy Struggles: The Suburban’s 15 MPG city and 20 MPG highway (5.3L V8) are underwhelming, especially with rising gas prices, making long trips costly.
- Less Premium Styling: Compared to the Yukon XL’s upscale Denali trims, the Suburban’s design feels more utilitarian, especially in lower trims like the LS.
- Base Trim Lacks Refinement: The LS trim’s cloth seats and basic interior materials pale in comparison to the Yukon XL’s more luxurious base offerings.
- Slightly Lower Towing Capacity: At 8,300 pounds max, the Suburban tows slightly less than the Yukon XL’s 8,400 pounds, which could matter for heavy trailers.
- Size Can Be Overwhelming: At 225.7 inches long, the Suburban is a beast to park in tight spaces, and I struggled in crowded lots.
- Premium Trims Get Pricey: The High Country trim approaches $95,523, closing the gap with the Yukon XL’s luxury models but without the same upscale vibe.
- No Super Cruise Option: Unlike the Yukon XL, the Suburban lacks GM’s hands-free Super Cruise system, a drawback for tech enthusiasts like me.
The Suburban’s fuel economy was a constant concern during my test drives—filling up the tank isn’t cheap. While I appreciated its practicality, the base trim’s interior felt a bit too basic for my taste, especially when I compared it to the Yukon XL’s flashier cabin. Parking this massive SUV in tight spaces was a challenge, and I missed the Yukon XL’s advanced tech like Super Cruise. For those needing to tow heavy loads, the slight difference in capacity might tip the scales toward the Yukon XL.
Pros Of the GMC Yukon XL
- Luxurious Interior: The Yukon XL, especially in Denali and Denali Ultimate trims, offers premium materials like Woodland Mahogany leather and 16-way power seats with massage functions.
- Slightly Better Fuel Economy: The 5.3L V8 achieves 16 MPG city, a marginal improvement over the Suburban’s 15 MPG, which adds up on long trips.
- Higher Towing Capacity: With a max of 8,400 pounds, the Yukon XL edges out the Suburban for those towing boats or trailers.
- Advanced Tech Options: Available Super Cruise and Night Vision systems give the Yukon XL a tech edge, perfect for long highway drives or low-visibility conditions.
- Premium Styling: The Denali’s chrome-heavy grille and 22-inch wheels make the Yukon XL feel more upscale and eye-catching than the Suburban.
- Better Resale Value: The Yukon XL retains 2.7% more of its value over five years compared to the Suburban, a boon for long-term owners.
- Magnetic Ride Control: Available on Denali trims, this feature delivers a smoother ride, which I noticed on bumpy roads compared to the Suburban.
The Yukon XL’s luxury was undeniable. The Denali trim’s interior felt like a high-end lounge, and features like Super Cruise made highway driving a breeze. The slightly better fuel economy and towing capacity were nice bonuses, especially for someone like me who loves road trips with a trailer in tow. The Yukon XL’s styling turned heads wherever I went, and its resale value gave me confidence in its long-term worth. It’s an SUV that balances practicality with a premium feel, making every drive feel special.
Cons Of the GMC Yukon XL
- Higher Starting Price: At $68,788, the Yukon XL’s base price is over $5,000 more than the Suburban’s, which feels steep for similar features.
- Smaller Base Infotainment Screen: The 15-inch touchscreen in the base SLE trim is smaller than the Suburban’s 17.7-inch, feeling less immersive.
- Fewer Trim Options: With five trims compared to the Suburban’s six, the Yukon XL offers less variety for buyers with specific needs.
- Premium Features Cost Extra: Features like Super Cruise and the panoramic sunroof are only available on higher trims, driving up the cost significantly.
- Fuel Economy Still Lacking: Even with a slight edge, 16 MPG city isn’t great, and the Yukon XL’s diesel option is pricier than the Suburban’s.
- Base Trim Feels Underwhelming: The SLE trim lacks the polish of higher trims, with fewer standard features than the Suburban’s base model.
- Similar Size Challenges: Like the Suburban, the Yukon XL’s 225.2-inch length makes parking tricky, especially in urban settings.
The Yukon XL’s higher price tag was hard to ignore, especially since the base model didn’t feel as well-equipped as the Suburban’s. The smaller touchscreen in the SLE trim was a letdown after experiencing the Suburban’s massive display. While the luxury trims are stunning, they come at a steep cost, and I found myself questioning whether the premium features justified the price. Like the Suburban, the Yukon XL’s size made it cumbersome in tight spaces, and fuel costs added up quickly.
Read More: My Thoughts On Ford Escape Vs. Mazda CX-5
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
No, the Yukon XL and Suburban are nearly identical in size, with the Suburban at 225.7 inches long and the Yukon XL at 225.2 inches. Both share a 134.1-inch wheelbase and offer the same cargo space (144.7 cubic feet max).
The Yukon XL is more expensive, starting at $68,788 compared to the Suburban’s $63,276. Higher trims like the Yukon XL Denali can reach $98,550, while the Suburban High Country tops out at $95,523.
The Chevrolet Suburban is the Chevy equivalent of the GMC Yukon XL. Both are built on the same platform, share similar dimensions, engines, and features, but differ in styling and pricing.
The Chevy Tahoe and GMC Yukon are similar, but the Tahoe is slightly cheaper (starting at $58,195 vs. $62,695 for the Yukon). The Yukon offers more premium styling and features like Super Cruise in higher trims, but the Tahoe provides better value for similar performance.
Conclusion: For Chevrolet Suburban and GMC Yukon XL
You’re probably wondering which SUV is the right pick for you, and I get it—it’s a tough call. After spending time with both the Chevrolet Suburban and GMC Yukon XL, I lean toward the Suburban for its unbeatable value. Its lower starting price, larger standard touchscreen, and slightly better reliability make it a practical choice for families or anyone needing massive space without breaking the bank. However, if you crave luxury and are willing to pay for it, the Yukon XL’s Denali trims deliver a premium experience with features like Super Cruise and a smoother ride. Both are fantastic, but your budget and priorities will decide the winner.
