CamLocker Vs. WeatherGuard Toolboxes: Which Is Better?

Toolboxes are a critical piece of equipment for many truck owners and contractors. Two of the most popular brands on the market are CamLocker and WeatherGuard.

But which one is the better choice for your needs?

This comprehensive guide examines the key differences between CamLocker and WeatherGuard toolboxes.

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	CamLocker	WeatherGuard
Materials	Aluminum	Steel
Locking System	Aluma-Tite rotary lock	LockHasp rotary lock
Lid Seal	Closed-cell foam gasket	Optional gasket
Hinges	Full wrap-around steel	Standard hinges
Smallest Size	34 inches	26 inches
Largest Size	72 inch double lid	108 inch standalone chest
Modularity	Stack & Lock system	Modular but no integrated lock
Average Weight	65-300 lbs	115-400+ lbs
Price Range	$400 – $2400	$500 – $1400+
Durability	Excellent	Excellent
Security	Excellent	Very Good
Storage Capacity	Very Good	Excellent
Ease of Use	Excellent	Very Good

Overview of CamLocker Toolboxes

CamLocker is a relatively new player in the toolbox game, founded in 2013.

However, they’ve quickly made a name for themselves by offering high-quality and innovative products.

CamLocker toolboxes feature sturdy diamond treadplate aluminum construction.

This makes them dent, rust, and corrosion resistant. The lid on CamLocker boxes uses a “cam over center” closing mechanism.

This allows for one-hand opening while keeping the lid securely shut. Most CamLocker toolboxes also have gas springs for smooth opening and closing of the lid.

One unique aspect of CamLocker is their patented “Aluma-Tite” security latching system. This uses an automotive-style rotary key tumbler lock on the front and rear latches. So you can lock the entire toolbox with a single key.

For even better security, some models have a hidden third lock underneath.

CamLocker toolboxes come in a range of sizes, from compact to giant. They offer standard top-access boxes, side mount units, and even large standalone chests.

Certain models are compatible with CamLocker’s modular Stack & Lock system. This allows you to stack and lock multiple toolboxes together into one unit.

Overview of WeatherGuard Toolboxes

WeatherGuard is probably the most well-known brand in the truck toolbox industry. They’ve been manufacturing toolboxes since 1960 and are known for their high-quality and durability.

WeatherGuard uses heavy-gauge steel construction on most of their toolboxes.

The steel is zinc-coated for maximum rust resistance.

They also apply a textured powder coat finish for even more protection from the elements.

WeatherGuard toolboxes employ a unique “LockHasp” rotary latch system.

This allows the entire box to be locked or unlocked with just one lock. Most models also have a gas spring for easy opening of the lid.

For added security, WeatherGuard offers an optional coded slam lock on some boxes. This auto-locks each time you close the lid.

WeatherGuard toolboxes come in a very wide range of sizes and styles. This includes crossover, side mount, and top mount toolboxes. They also offer huge standalone storage chests and crane boxes. WeatherGuard provides modular and stackable toolboxes as well for additional flexibility.

Durability Comparison

One of the most important factors for any toolbox is durability. You need it to stand up to years of use as well as outdoor conditions like rain, mud, or snow.

Overall, most users agree that both CamLocker and WeatherGuard make very robust, high-quality products. However, there are some differences in materials and construction:

• Materials: CamLocker uses thick diamond treadplate aluminum for maximum dent and corrosion resistance. WeatherGuard relies on heavy-gauge zinc-coated steel for the most durable construction.
• Hinges: CamLocker boxes have full wrap-around steel hinges secured with multiple bolts. WeatherGuard uses more standard hinge designs which may be more prone to loosening over time.
• Latching: Both brands use secure rotary latch systems that require a key to open. But CamLocker’s unique Aluma-Tite system may provide better protection against prying or forced entry attempts.
• Gaskets: All CamLocker boxes come standard with a thick closed-cell foam gasket lid seal. This provides superior dust and water protection. WeatherGuard boxes lack a gasket, though you can add it as an option.
• Modularity: CamLocker and WeatherGuard both offer stackable toolboxes you can interconnect. But CamLocker’s Stack & Lock system aligns and locks multiple units together into one cohesive block.

Overall, CamLocker likely has a slight edge for serious durability. Factors like the aluminum material, heavy-duty hinges, and lid gaskets give their boxes the ultimate protection in harsh environments. But WeatherGuard is certainly no slouch either. Their steel construction is extremely rigid and resilient.

Security Comparison

Picking a toolbox with excellent security features is also a top concern for many truck owners. Keeping your expensive tools and gear locked safely away is a must. Once again, CamLocker and WeatherGuard both deliver excellent security:

• Locking: They both use a secure rotary latch with a key tumbler that locks the entire lid shut. WeatherGuard’s slam latch versions have the added benefit of auto-locking.
• Lock design: CamLocker’s patented Aluma-Tite lock is incredibly robust and pick/drill resistant thanks to its automotive-style design. However, some may find WeatherGuard’s locks slightly easier to use.
• Hidden locks: Select CamLocker models have an additional hidden lock mounted inside the toolbox for even better protection against break-ins. WeatherGuard lacks any equivalent hidden locks.
• Modularity: When toolboxes are stacked/locked together, CamLocker’s system forms one integrated block that’s harder to disassemble. WeatherGuard’s modular system can still be detached box by box.

Overall CamLocker once again edges out WeatherGuard slightly when it comes to security. The Aluma-Tite locks, optional hidden locks, and integrated stacking lock system make their boxes practically impenetrable to thieves.

But don’t count WeatherGuard out either – their locks and slam latch provide excellent protection for most owners.

Storage Capacity Comparison

Another vital feature for any toolbox is how much gear you can fit inside. The larger the storage capacity, the more tools, parts, and other items you can bring with you. Here’s how CamLocker and WeatherGuard toolbox sizes stack up:

• Compact sizes: CamLocker’s smallest single lid toolbox is 34” long. WeatherGuard offers compact boxes down to 26” length to fit smaller trucks.
• Full-size boxes: A standard full-width CamLocker single lid box is roughly 96” long. WeatherGuard’s full-size single lid units can be up to 108” long.
• Double lid chests: CamLocker double lid chests max out around 54” long. WeatherGuard’s largest double lid chest is 72” long for even more room.
• Additional storage: CamLocker doesn’t offer standalone chests or crane boxes. But WeatherGuard has huge standalone options up to 108” long for maximum storage space.

So when it comes to pure storage capacity, WeatherGuard leads the way. If you need to fit a ton of tools and gear, their extra-large full-size and standalone boxes deliver. But CamLocker still provides decently sized toolboxes for most general needs.

Weight Comparison

Depending on your truck and how you mount your toolbox, weight may also be an important consideration. Heavier boxes could affect your suspension and fuel economy. They’re also harder to remove or maneuver during installation. Here’s how the weights compare:

• Material weight: CamLocker’s diamond plate aluminum construction is much lighter than WeatherGuard’s steel boxes. Aluminum weighs about 1/3 as much as steel.
• Small boxes: A typical small CamLocker box weighs 65-85 lbs. WeatherGuard’s steel versions weigh around 115-130 lbs.
• Full-size boxes: Full-width CamLocker boxes weigh 115-155 lbs. Full WeatherGuard boxes are 185-220 lbs.
• Large boxes: Extra-large standalone WeatherGuard chests can weigh 400+ lbs! The heaviest CamLocker box is their 72” double lid at around 300 lbs max.

Across the board, CamLocker’s aluminium build gives them a clear weight advantage over WeatherGuard’s steel boxes. This can make a big difference for easier installation, removal, and mobility. Just be aware even “light” aluminum boxes are still heavy – get help lifting!

Price Comparison

The final factor to consider is cost and value. CamLocker and WeatherGuard compete in roughly the same premium price bracket. But there are some differences:

• Base models: CamLocker’s smaller steel boxes start around $400. WeatherGuard’s smallest steel box is $500.
• Aluminum boxes: CamLocker aluminum boxes range $1200 – $2400 for full-size single lid models.
• Large boxes: Extra-large WeatherGuard chests are $1400+. Comparable CamLocker boxes cost $2000+.
• Per inch of space: Overall, WeatherGuard tends to provide more storage space per dollar spent. CamLocker emphasizes quality and security over max capacity.
• Sales: WeatherGuard runs frequent promotions on their toolboxes. CamLocker rarely discounts their prices.

At the end of the day, you get what you pay for with both brands. DIY buyers on a strict budget may lean towards WeatherGuard. But CamLocker offers superior construction, security, and durability. Professional contractors should consider them strongly despite their premium pricing.

Ease of Use Comparison

Beyond core features and pricing, we also need to consider how easy CamLocker and WeatherGuard toolboxes are to use in the real world:

• Installation: CamLocker boxes tend to have more pre-drilled mounting points and hardware included for easier install. WeatherGuard is more barebones, requiring you to purchase mounting brackets/bolts separately.
• Opening/closing: Both brands use gas struts for easy opening. But CamLocker’s “cam over” lock allows for quick one-hand opening without keys. WeatherGuard’s rotary latch requires unlocking before opening the lid.
• Accessibility: WeatherGuard offers more models like side-mount boxes for greater accessibility without climbing into your truck bed. Most CamLocker boxes sit flat in the bed for top access.
• Modularity: Both have stackable toolboxes. But CamLocker’s Stack & Lock is easier to horizontally connect multiple units. WeatherGuard requires separating each box to stack.

For install and opening/closing, CamLocker delivers a bit more convenience and quick access. But WeatherGuard counters with greater mounting flexibility and side box options. Overall usability is close between the two brands.

Winner?

With all said and done, is there an obvious winner between CamLocker vs WeatherGuard toolboxes? In short – it depends! Each brand has pros and cons:

CamLocker Advantages

• Superior durability from aluminium material and construction
• Best in class security features like Aluma-Tite locks
• Lighter weight from aluminum build
• Easier installation right out of the box
• Fast “cam over” opening/closing operation

WeatherGuard Advantages

• Broader range of toolbox sizes and styles
• Maximum storage capacity with extra-large standalone chests
• Lower cost per cubic inch of storage space
• More frequent promotions and sales
• Easier side box access on trucks

Also Read: Top ROAM Case Competitors.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Final Thoughts

There’s compelling reasons to pick either brand. For professional contractors and those focused on security, CamLocker is hard to beat. But for DIY users wanting max storage at lower cost, WeatherGuard excels.

Ultimately it comes down what features matter most for how you plan to use your toolbox. Either way, both CamLocker and WeatherGuard make incredibly sturdy, secure, well-built toolboxes that will serve you well for years to come.

You really can’t go wrong with either brand.