Cadillac CTS Vs. Cadillac XTS: A Personal Comparison of Two Luxury Sedans

As a car enthusiast who’s spent years behind the wheel of luxury sedans, I’ve always been drawn to Cadillac’s blend of performance, style, and comfort. The Cadillac CTS and XTS, two discontinued yet iconic models, still spark debate among buyers looking for pre-owned luxury.

In this article, I’ll share my firsthand experience comparing these sedans, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses to help you decide which fits your driving style. Through a detailed pros and cons analysis and real-world insights, I aim to guide you toward the right choice for your next ride.

Cadillac CTS Vs. XTS Comparison

My Experience With the Cadillac CTS

I’ll never forget the first time I slid into the driver’s seat of a 2016 Cadillac CTS. The cabin felt like a cockpit, with sharp lines and a driver-focused layout that screamed performance.

The CTS, built on GM’s rear-wheel-drive Alpha platform, was Cadillac’s answer to sporty European sedans like the BMW 5 Series.

Over a weekend test drive, I pushed it through winding backroads and city streets, and it left an impression with its nimble handling and potent engine options.

The CTS comes in multiple flavors, from the base 2.0L turbo four-cylinder to the fire-breathing 640-hp CTS-V. I drove the 3.6L V6 model with 335 horsepower, which felt responsive yet refined, paired with an 8-speed automatic that shifted smoothly.

The Magnetic Ride Control suspension, a standout feature, adjusted to road conditions in milliseconds, making bumpy roads feel like glass.

The interior, wrapped in leatherette with wood and chrome accents, exuded luxury, though the CUE infotainment system was a bit clunky, especially pre-2016 models. On the highway, it was quiet, but the back seat felt snug for taller passengers, and the 13.7-cubic-foot trunk was adequate but not generous.

What struck me most was the CTS’s balance of sportiness and comfort. It’s a midsize sedan that feels athletic, with precise steering and a rear-drive bias that makes it fun to toss into corners.

However, it’s not perfect—more on that later. For drivers who crave a dynamic ride with luxury touches, the CTS is a compelling choice, especially in the used market where prices have dropped significantly since its 2019 discontinuation.

Read More: My Thoughts On Acura MDX Vs. Volvo XC90

Pros Of the Cadillac CTS

• Sporty Handling: The CTS’s rear-wheel-drive platform and available Magnetic Ride Control deliver sharp, responsive handling that rivals European competitors like the BMW 5 Series. On twisty roads, it feels planted and eager, with steering that’s precise and communicative. I found myself grinning during a spirited drive through a hilly stretch, as the suspension soaked up bumps while keeping the car composed.
• Powerful Engine Options: From the 268-hp 2.0L turbo to the monstrous 640-hp V8 in the CTS-V, there’s an engine for every taste. The 3.6L V6 I tested had ample power for merging onto highways, and the twin-turbo V6 in the V-Sport trim offers 420 hp for thrill-seekers without the V’s price tag.
• Luxurious Interior: The CTS’s cabin is a standout, with premium materials like leather, wood, and chrome. The front seats are supportive, and features like heated seats and a heated steering wheel add comfort. The 11-speaker Bose system pumped out crisp audio, making my playlists sound better than ever.
• Advanced Technology: Standard features like an 8-inch CUE touchscreen, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto keep you connected. The available Wi-Fi hotspot was a lifesaver during a road trip when I needed to stream navigation. Safety tech, including Forward Collision Alert and Lane Keep Assist, adds peace of mind.
• Affordable Used Pricing: Since its discontinuation in 2019, the CTS has become a bargain in the pre-owned market. I’ve seen 2016-2018 models with low miles priced between $20,000 and $30,000, offering luxury and performance at a fraction of their original MSRP.

The CTS’s blend of performance and luxury makes it a joy for drivers who want a car that’s as fun on a backroad as it is comfortable on a long commute. Its sporty edge sets it apart in Cadillac’s lineup, appealing to those who prioritize driving dynamics over outright space.

Cons Of the Cadillac CTS

• Cramped Rear Seat: The CTS’s midsize dimensions mean rear legroom and headroom are tight, especially for taller passengers. During my test, two friends over 6 feet complained about feeling squeezed in the back, making it less ideal for frequent carpoolers or families.
• Small Trunk: With only 13.7 cubic feet of cargo space, the CTS lags behind competitors like the XTS. I struggled to fit a weekend’s worth of luggage for three people, and golf bags were a tight squeeze, which could frustrate those needing more storage.
• CUE System Issues: The CUE infotainment, especially in pre-2016 models, is sluggish and unintuitive. The touch-sensitive controls frustrated me during my drive, as they were slow to respond, and the gel-based touchscreen in early models was prone to cracking, per online forums.
• Reliability Concerns: Some model years, like 2007 and 2009, have reported issues with timing chains and steering wheel sensors, per consumer complaints. While my 2016 model felt solid, I’d recommend checking maintenance records for used CTSs to avoid costly repairs.
• Fuel Economy: The base 2.0L turbo gets respectable 22/30 mpg, but the V6 and V8 options are thirstier, dipping to 16/24 mpg in the CTS-V. For daily commuters like me, this could add up at the pump, especially with premium fuel requirements.

The CTS’s sporty focus comes at the cost of practicality and reliability in some cases, which might deter buyers who need a more versatile daily driver. Still, its driving dynamics are hard to beat for the price.

My Experience With the Cadillac XTS

When I first drove a 2018 Cadillac XTS, it felt like stepping into a modern take on Cadillac’s classic luxury ethos. The XTS, built on a front-wheel-drive platform shared with the Chevy Impala, prioritizes comfort and space over sportiness.

During a week-long test, I used it for everything from city errands to a long highway trip, and its plush ride and roomy interior stood out.

The XTS offers two 3.6L V6 engines: a naturally aspirated version with 304 hp and a twin-turbo V-Sport with 410 hp. I drove the standard V6, paired with a 6-speed automatic, which delivered smooth, effortless power.

The Magnetic Ride Control, available on higher trims, made potholes disappear, and the cabin was whisper-quiet, thanks to Bose’s Acoustic Noise Cancellation. The interior, with soft leather and a spacious back seat, felt like a lounge, and the 18-cubic-foot trunk swallowed my groceries and luggage with ease.

However, the XTS isn’t as engaging to drive as the CTS. Its front-wheel-drive layout and softer suspension prioritize comfort over cornering prowess, which I noticed on curvy roads where it felt less planted. The CUE system, while improved in later models, still lagged at times.

For buyers seeking a spacious, comfortable cruiser, the XTS is a strong contender, especially in the used market where its depreciation makes it a value-packed option.

Pros Of the Cadillac XTS

• Spacious Interior: The XTS’s 104.2 cubic feet of passenger space is a game-changer. I comfortably fit three adults in the back during a group outing, and the rear legroom and headroom were generous, making it ideal for families or those who prioritize passenger comfort.
• Large Trunk: With 18 cubic feet of cargo space, the XTS easily handled my weekend trip luggage, including two suitcases and a cooler. It’s perfect for road trips or airport runs, outshining the CTS in practicality.
• Smooth Ride Quality: The XTS’s suspension, especially with Magnetic Ride Control, delivers a cushioned ride that rivals top-tier luxury sedans. Driving over rough city streets, I barely felt bumps, and long highway stretches were serene.
• Advanced Safety Features: The XTS includes standard Forward Collision Alert, Lane Keep Assist, and Automatic Emergency Braking, plus available Rainsense wipers. These gave me confidence in tricky weather, especially during a rainy drive where the wipers adjusted automatically.
• Value for Money: Like the CTS, the XTS’s discontinuation in 2019 has driven down used prices. I found 2016-2018 models priced between $18,000 and $28,000, offering near-flagship luxury at a budget-friendly cost.

The XTS shines as a comfortable, spacious sedan that’s perfect for long drives or chauffeuring passengers. Its focus on luxury and practicality makes it a compelling choice for those who value comfort over sportiness.

Cons Of the Cadillac XTS

• Less Engaging Handling: The XTS’s front-wheel-drive platform and softer suspension make it less fun on winding roads. During my test, it leaned more in corners than the CTS, feeling more like a cruiser than a sports sedan.
• Outdated Transmission: The 6-speed automatic, while smooth, isn’t as refined as the CTS’s 8-speed. I noticed slower shifts during quick acceleration, which could frustrate drivers seeking a responsive feel.
• Reliability Issues: The XTS has reported suspension problems, particularly with Magnetic Ride Control struts, which can cost $1,600 to replace, per forums. Timing chain issues in early 3.6L V6 models also raise concerns, so I’d advise thorough inspections.
• CUE Infotainment Woes: Like the CTS, the XTS’s CUE system can be laggy, especially in 2013-2015 models. I found the touchscreen unresponsive at times, and older gel-based screens are prone to failure, according to owner reviews.
• Fuel Efficiency: The XTS’s 19/28 mpg (FWD) is decent but trails competitors like the Genesis G80. The twin-turbo V6 is even less efficient, which hit my wallet during a week of mixed driving.

The XTS’s focus on comfort comes at the expense of driving excitement, and potential maintenance costs could be a drawback for budget-conscious buyers. Still, its spaciousness is hard to beat.

Read More: My Thoughts On Acura MDX Vs. Lexus GX

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: For Cadillac CTS or XTS

Choosing between the Cadillac CTS and XTS comes down to what you value most in a luxury sedan. If you’re like me and crave a car that’s fun to drive, with sharp handling and powerful engine options, the CTS is your pick. Its sporty edge and upscale interior make it a standout, though its smaller cabin and trunk might not suit everyone. If you prioritize comfort, space, and a smooth ride for long trips or family outings, the XTS is the better choice, offering a roomier interior and larger trunk at a similar price. Both are fantastic used buys, but test drive them to feel the difference. Whichever you choose, you’re getting Cadillac’s signature luxury at a steal.